Forensic and pharmaceutical study of the violations of the rules for medicines circulation for pharmaceutical provision of cancer patients

Authors

  • В. В. Шаповалов Департамент охорони здоров’я ХОДА, Ukraine
  • В. В. Шаповалов Харківська медична академія післядипломної освіти, Ukraine
  • В. А. Шаповалова Харківська медична академія післядипломної освіти, Україна, Ukraine
  • О. В. Куликова Харківська медична академія післядипломної освіти, Ukraine

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21564/2225-6555.2016.1.64263

Keywords:

circulation, analgesic drugs, pharmaceutical provision, cancer patients, forensic pharmacy, criminalistics, recipes, violations, forensic and pharmaceutical practice

Abstract

Problem setting. Conducted a comparison of the systems of pharmaceutical provision with pharmaceutical care – providing medical products inUkraine and abroad through the introduction of health insurance and reimbursement of medicines from the state budget.

Recent research and publications analysis. Quantitative analysis of the incidence of malignant neoplasms and mortality, the number of pharmacies inUkraine and Kharkiv region; the level of public spending on the program to combat cancer. Noted that the market of voluntary medical insurance inUkraine is underdeveloped (covering only 3% of the population) for a complete provision of population with necessary medicines and medical services. The basic conditions for the successful treatment of cancer. Analyzed legislative framework regulating the circulation of medicines for cancer patients inUkraine.

Paper objective. The review violation circulation of medicines, pharmacy made by specialists in providing cancer. Determined that prescription drugs helps minimize forensic pharmaceutical risks (side effects, abuse, etc.). Processed work of scientists ofUkraine and other countries to ensure the cancer drugs of different pharmacological clinical, legal nomenclature and classification of legal groups.

Conclusions of the research. Proposed standard-setting initiatives to improve the legal system "doctor-patient-pharmacist" and narcotic drugs for pharmaceutical providing for patients with cancer at discounted prescription from pharmacies in Ukraine and Kharkov region: expanding the definition of "pharmacy"; promoting the opening of pharmacies in rural areas and increase the number of pharmacies that carry out activities related to narcotic drugs

Author Biographies

В. В. Шаповалов, Департамент охорони здоров’я ХОДА

д-р фарм. наук, проф.,
начальник відділу фармації управління медичної та фармацевтичної діяльності
Департаменту охорони здоров’я ХОДА

В. В. Шаповалов, Харківська медична академія післядипломної освіти

канд. фарм. наук, д-р філософії, доц., доцент кафедри медичного та фармацевтичного права, загальної і клінічної фармації

В. А. Шаповалова, Харківська медична академія післядипломної освіти, Україна

д-р фарм. наук, проф., завідувач кафедри медичного та фармацевтичного права, загальної і клінічної фармації

О. В. Куликова, Харківська медична академія післядипломної освіти

здобувач кафедри медичного та фармацевтичного права, загальної і клінічної фармації

References

Get'man, A.P. (2009). Vytoky nauky ekolohichnoho prava Ukrayiny. Problemy zakonnosti, issue 100, 165–174 [in Ukrainian].

Hospodars'kyy kodeks Ukrayiny vid 16.01.2003 № 436-IV. (2003). Vidom. Verkhov. Rady Ukrayiny, 18 [in Ukrainian].

Hudzenko, O P. (2004). Naukovi osnovy udoskonalennya likars'koho zabezpechennya pil'hovykh katehoriy naselennya promyslovykh rehioniv doctor’s thesis. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

Datsyuk, N.O., Volokh, D.S., Sholoyko, N.V. (2012). Analiz spozhyvannya narkotychnykh anal'hetykiv v Ukrayini (za danymy mizhnarodnoho komitetu z kontrolyu za narkotykamy). Farmatsevtychnyy chasopys, 2, 103–106 [in Ukrainian].

Yevtushenko, O.M., Mnushko, Z.M., Nemtsova, V.D. (2010). Upravlinnya, ekonomika ta zabezpechennya yakosti v farmatsiyi. Farmatsevtychnyy chasopys, 4 (12), 50–56 [in Ukrainian].

Yel'nykova, M.O. (2015). Udoskonalennya mekhanizmu realizatsiyi ta zakhystu prav lyudyny v Ukrayini. Problemy zakonnosti, 129, 76–83 [in Ukrainian].

Pro litsenzuvannya vydiv hospodars'koyi diyal'nosti: Zakon Ukrayiny vid 02.03.2015 № 222-XIII. (2015). Vidom. Verkhov. Rady Ukrayiny, 23 [in Ukrainian].

Pro likars'ki zasoby: Zakon Ukrayiny vid 04.04.1996 № 123/96-VR. (1996). Vidom. Verkhov. Rady Ukrayiny, 22, 86 [in Ukrainian].

Osnovy zakonodavstva Ukrayiny pro okhoronu zdorov"ya: Zakon Ukrayiny vid 19.11.1992 № 2801-XII. (1993). Vidom. Verkhov. Rady Ukrayiny, 4 [in Ukrainian].

Pro zatverdzhennya Zahal'noderzhavnoyi prohramy borot'by z onkolohichnymy zakhvoryuvannyamy na period do 2016 roku: Zakon Ukrayiny vid 23.12.2009 № 1794-17. (2010). Vidom. Verkhov. Rady Ukrayiny, 11, 316 [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalov, V.V. (mol.), Shapovalov, V.V., Shapovalova, V.O. (2014). Rohozhnikova Zasady derzhavnoyi polityky u sudovo-farmatsevtychnomu vyvchenni problemy pil'hovoho zabezpechennya likars'kymy zasobamy onkolohichnykh khvorykh z komorbidnoyu narkotychnoyu zalezhnistyu na osnovi farmatsevtychnoho prava: Sbornyk nauchnykh trudov Sworld. Yvanovo: Markova AD. Vol. 30, issue 3 (36), 70–83 [in Russian].

Zbrozhek, S.I. (2012). Udoskonalennya derzhavnoyi kontseptsiyi obihu likars'kykh zasobiv na zasadakh farmatsevtychnoho prava. Extended abstract of candidate’s thesis. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalova, V.A., Shapovalov, V.V. (ml.), Shapovalov, V.V., Terekhova, O.V. (2015). Yzuchenye dostupnosty narkotycheskykh anal'hetykov v ramkakh formulyarnoy systemy Rossyy y Ukrayny s pozytsyy farmatsevtycheskoho prava. Farmatsyya, 5, 15–20 [in Russian].

Komarov, V.V. (2009). Rishennya Yevropeys'koho sudu z prav lyudyny ta Konstytutsiynoho sudu Ukrayiny: problema konkurentsiyi. Problemy zakonnosti, issue 100, 31–41 [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalova, V.A., Chernyh, V.P., Shapovalov, V.V. et al. (Eds.). (2007). Konstytutsiya Ukrayiny. Farmatsevtychne pravo i dokazova farmatsiya v systemi pravovidnosyn derzhava–zakon–vyrobnyk–optovyk–menedzher–likar–patsiyent–provizor–liky–kontrolyuyuchi ta pravookhoronni orhany: materialy nauk.-prakt. konf., 16 lyst. [in Ukrainian].

Kotvytskaya, A.A., Korobova, E.S. (2013). Analyz sovremennikh tendentsyy farmatsevtycheskoho obespechenyya l'hotnikh katehoryy naselenyya v stranakh SNH. Nauchnie vedomosty Belhorodskoho natsyonal'noho unyversyteta (ser. Medytsyna. Farmatsyya), 11-2 (154), vol. 22, 18–25 [in Russian].

Lynskyy, Y. (2008). Spetsrezhym dlya dozy. Tramadol kak zerkalo natsyonal'noy polytyky v otnoshenyy narkotykov. Zerkalo nedely, 22, 4 [in Russian].

Shapovalov, V.V. (ml.), Shapovalov, V.V., Ryshchenko, O.A. et al. (2014). Medytsynskoe y farmatsevtycheskoe pravo: sravnytel'niy analyz klynyko-farmakolohycheskykh hrupp lekarstvennikh sredstv, yspol'zuemikh v psykhyatryy y narkolohyy, v ramkakh formulyarnoy systemy Rossyy y Ukrayny. Nauchnye vedomosty Belhorodskoho hosudarstvennoho unyversyteta. (ser. Medytsyna. Farmatsyya, 4 (175), issue 25, 213–220 [in Russian].

Pro deklaruvannya zminy optovo-vidpusknykh tsin na likars'ki zasoby stanom na 25 bereznya 2014 roku ta vnesennya yikh do reyestru» vid 02.04.2014 № 240: Nakaz MOZ Ukrayiny. (2014). Apteka, 936 (15). Retrived from: http://www.apteka.ua/article/287746. [in Ukrainian].

Ukrayiny «Pro zatverdzhennya Pravyl vypysuvannya retseptiv ta vymoh-zamovlen' na likars'ki zasoby i vyroby medychnoho pryznachennya, Poryadku vidpusku likars'kykh zasobiv i vyrobiv medychnoho pryznachennya z aptek ta yikh strukturnykh pidrozdiliv, Instruktsiyi pro poryadok zberihannya, obliku ta znyshchennya retsepturnykh blankiv ta vymoh-zamovlen': Nakaz MOZ vid 19.07.2005 № 360. (2005). Ofitsiynyy visnyk Ukrayiny, 29, 452 [in Ukrainian].

Pro zatverdzhennya Litsenziynykh umov provadzhennya hospodars'koyi diyal'nosti z vyrobnytstva likars'kykh zasobiv, optovoyi, rozdribnoyi torhivli likars'kymy zasobamy: Nakaz MOZ Ukrayiny vid 31.10.2011 № 723. (2011). Ofitsiynyy visnyk Ukrayiny, 99, 189 [in Ukrainian].

Osnovni pokaznyky zdorov"ya naselennya ta diyal'nosti zakladiv okhorony zdorov`ya Kharkivs'koyi oblasti za 2013-2014. (2015). Kharkiv: KhOIATsMS DOZ KhODA [in Ukrainian].

Pashkov, V. Diyal'nist' ombudsmena z prav patsiyentiv yak zasib rehulyuyuchoho vplyvu derzhavy. Retrived from: http://www.apteka.ua/article/339724 [in Ukrainian].

Petryshyn, O. V. (2009). Verkhovenstvo prava v systemi prava. Problemy zakonnosti. issue 100, 18–30 [in Ukrainian].

Peshekhodnaya dostupnost' aptek dolzhna byt' 300-700 metrov. Retrived from: http://ura.dn.ua/15.05.2012/124796.html [in Russian].

Pro poryadok zakupivli likars'kykh zasobiv zakladamy ta ustanovamy okhorony zdorov"ya, shcho finansuyut'sya z byudzhetu: postanova KMU vid 05.09.1996 № 1071 v ost. red. vid 14.11.2013 № 972. (2013). Ofitsiynyy visnyk Ukrayiny, 91, 351 [in Ukrainian].

Pro vporyadkuvannya bezoplatnoho ta pil'hovoho vidpusku likars'kykh zasobiv za retseptamy likariv u razi ambulatornoho likuvannya okremykh hrup naselennya ta za pevnymy katehoriyamy zakhvoryuvan': postanova KMU vid 17.08.1998 № 1303. (1998). Ofitsiynyy visnyk Ukrayiny, 33, 61 [in Ukrainian].

Pytannya deklaruvannya zminy optovo-vidpusknykh tsin na likars'ki zasoby ta vyroby medychnoho pryznachennya: postanova KMU vid 02.07.2014 № 240. (2014). Ofitsiynyy visnyk Ukrayiny, 56, 54 [in Ukrainian].

Pro zatverdzhennya Poryadku provadzhennya diyal'nosti, pov"yazanoyi z obihom narkotychnykh zasobiv, psykhotropnykh rechovyn i prekursoriv, ta kontrolyu za yikh obihom: postanova KMU vid 03.06.2009 № 589. (2009). Ofitsiynyy visnyk Ukrayiny, 44, 31 [in Ukrainian].

Pres-sluzhba MOZ Ukrayiny. 4 lyutoho – Vsesvitniy den' borot'by z onkolohichnymy zakhvoryuvannyamy. (2015). Ofitsiynyy veb-sayt MOZ Ukrayiny. 04.02.2015. Retrived from: http://moz.gov.ua/ua/portal/pre_20150204_a.html [in Ukrainian].

Rak. Pallyatyvnaya pomoshch'. (2015). Ofitsiynyy sayt VOOZ. 28.07.2015. Retrived from: http://www.who.int/cancer/palliative/ru/ [in Russian].

Reyestr mists' provadzhennya diyal'nosti z optovoyi ta rozdribnoyi torhivli likars'kymy zasobamy Derzhavnoyi sluzhby Ukrayiny z likars'kykh zasobiv. Ofitsiynyy veb-sayt Derzhavnoyi sluzhby Ukrayiny z likars'kykh zasobiv. Retrived from: http://portal.diklz.gov.ua/PublicSite/TradeLicense/TradeLicenseList.aspx [in Ukrainian].

Solovyov, O.S., Babintseva, L.Yu., Mintser, O.P., Ponomarenko, M.S. (2013). Rol' informatyzatsiyi farmatsevtychnoho rynku v zabezpechenni upravlinnya obihom likars'kykh zasobiv (povidoml. 1). Med. inf-ka ta inzheneriya, 4, 16–19 [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalov, V.V., Shapovalov, V.V. (ml.), Shapovalova, V.A., Terekhova, O.V. (2015). Sudebnaya farmatsyya v hosudarstvennoy kontseptsyy protyvodeystvyya narkotyzatsyy naselenyya Ukrayny y Rossyy dlya povyshenyya dostupnosty narkotycheskykh anal'hetykov. Nauchnyy rezul'tat, vol. 1, 1 (3), 30–50. (ser. Medytsyna y farmatsyya). Retrived from: http://rr.bsu.edu.ru/images/issue3/medicine/medicine.pdf [in Russian].

Shapovalov, V.V. (ml.), Shapovalov, V.V., Zbrozhek, S.Y. et al. (2015). Sudebno-farmatsevtycheskaya kharakterystyka pravonarushenyy v sfere oborota sredstv y veshchestv razlychnykh klassyfykatsyonno-pravovykh hrupp, Farmatsyya Kazakhstana, 3 (166), 46–50 [in Russian].

Tatsiy, V.Ya. (2009). Prava lyudyny i hromadyanyna yak pidgruntya vdoskonalennya zakonodavstva Ukrayiny. Problemy zakonnosti, issue 100, 6–17 [in Ukrainian].

Tereshchenko, L.V., Nemchenko, A.S. (2012). Otsinka problemy retsepturnoho vidpusku v Ukrayini. Upravlinnya, ekonomika ta zabezpechennya yakosti v farmatsiyi, 4 (24), 38–44 [in Ukrainian].

Tolochko, V.M., Haliy, L.V., Vasilin, V.Yu. (2007). Doslidzhennya orhanizatsiyi pratsi provizora apteky / V. M. Tolochko, // Farmatsevtychnyy zhurnal, 3, 48–55 [in Ukrainian].

Tonkov, E.E. (2007). Doverye naselenyya k hosudarstvu – neobkhodymoe uslovye эffektyvnoho protyvodeystvyya prestupnosty. Nauchnye vedomosty Belhorodskoho hosudarstvennoho unyversyteta. (ser: Fylosofyya. Sotsyolohyya. Pravo), 2 (33), 139–149 [in Russian].

Shapovalova, V.O., Shapovalov, V.V., Khalin, M.M. et al. (2010). Farmatsevtychne zakonodavstvo: navch. posib. [2nd ed.]. Kharkiv, (ser.: Farmatsevtychne pravo) [in Ukrainian].

Chepurko, V. (2015). Evropa othorazhyvaet·sya ot bezhentsev. Komsomol'skaya pravda v Ukrayne. 21.09.2015. Retrived from: http://kp.ua/life/513588-evropa-othorazhyvaetsia-ot-bezhentsev [in Russian].

Chkan, I. O. (2015). Tendentsiyi rozvytku dobrovil'noho medychnoho strakhuvannya v Ukrayini. Finansovyy prostir, 1 (17), 292–295 [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalov, V.V. (mol.). (2009). Sudovo-farmatsevtychni doslidzhennya obihu osoblyvo nebezpechnykh narkotychnykh zasobiv u svitli natsional'noyi bezpeky. Extended abstract of candidate’s thesis. – Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalov, V.V. (mol.), Sosin, I.K. (2009). Dokazova farmatsiya. Otsinka vykorystannya preparatu ketanov pry bol'ovomu syndromi u khvorykh z alkohol'noyu i narkotychnoyu zalezhnistyu v ramkakh paliatyvnoyi dopomohy. Ukrayins'kyy visnyk psykhonevrolohiyi, vol. 17, issue. 2 (dod.), 152–155 [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalov, V.V. (2005). Orhanizatsiyno-pravovi pidkhody do rozrobky kombinovanykh likars'kykh zasobiv na osnovi psykhoaktyvnykh rechovyn dlya poperedzhennya i likuvannya narkomaniyi. Extended abstract of doctor’s thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalova, V.O. (1996). Stvorennya dytyachykh likars'kykh form na osnovi vidomykh farmakolohichnykh substantsiy. Extended abstract of doctor’s thesis. – Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

Shapovalova, V.O. (2004). Farmatsevtychne pravo v narkolohiyi. V.O. Shapovalova, I.K. Sosin, V.V. Shapovalov (Eds.). Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

Yakovlyeva L.V. (2009). Farmakoekonomika: navch. posib. Vinnytsya: Nova knyha [in Ukrainian].

Lemari, Alexandre. (2015). Rfugis: Sarkozyveutre fonder Schengen. 09.10.2015. Retrived from: http://www.lemonde.fr/politique/article/2015/09/10/ refugies-sarkozy-veut-refonder-schengen_4751266_823448.html.

Cancer. (2015). Factsheet № 297. February 2015. Retrived from: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs297/ru/.

Fleck, F. (2015). Expanding prepay ment is key to universal health coverage. Bulletin of the WHO. 2015. Retrived from: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/notes/2012/uhc_prepayment_20120903/en/.

Health Insurance in Poland – all you need to know. (2015). Foreigners inPoland. 08.09.2015. Retrived from: http://www.foreignersinpoland.com/health-insurance-in-poland/.

In the global health care crisis, pharmaiscrucial. (2013). ELSEVIER. By Ibis Snchez-Serrano Postedon. 03.09.2013. Retrived from: https://www.elsevier.com/connect/in-the-global-health-care-crisis-pharma-is-crucial.

Tancoa, Kimberson, Brueraa, Sofia E., Brueraa Eduardo. (2014). Insurance company denial of payment and en for cedchangesint hetype and dose of opioid analgesics for patients with cancer pain. Palliative and Supportive Care. December 2014, vol. 12, issue 6, 515–518.

Rau, K.M., Chen, J. S., Wu, H.B. et al. (2015). The impact of pain control on physical and psychiatric functions of cancer patients: a nation-widesurvey inTaiwan. Jpn J Clin Oncol. Aug. 19.

Krobot, K.J., Miller, W.C., Kaufman, J.S. et al. (2004). The disparity in access to new medication by type of heal thin surance: lessons from Germany. Med Care. May 2004, 42 (5), vol. 4, 87–91. Retrived from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ pubmed/15083110.

Von, Stephan Ozsvath. (2015). Grenzschlie ung Ungarnsf Flchtlinge Neuer Korridoraufder Westbalkanroute. 17.10.2015. Retrived from: https://www.tagesschau.de/ausland/ungarn-grenze-kroatien-107.html.

Published

2016-03-23

Issue

Section

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE AND CRIMINALISTICS. FORENSIC EXAMINATION